Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

How "real" are your characters? 

39%
20 deviants said I think all characters are an extention of the author, even (or especially) the subconcious facets.
35%
18 deviants said My characters often have a mind of their own.
12%
6 deviants said Reality is a subjective notion.
10%
5 deviants said I am always 100% in control of my writing.
4%
2 deviants said You made them up. Of course they aren't real.
0%
No deviants said Rambly journal ahoy! silverinkblot.deviantart.com/j…

Devious Comments

:icondrippingwords:
DrippingWords Featured By Owner Dec 3, 2012  Student Writer
I'd say something, but ~SurrealCachinnation already said everything that was on my mind XD
Reply
:iconsurrealcachinnation:
SurrealCachinnation Featured By Owner Dec 2, 2012   Writer
Extension of the author. I don't think it is possible to create something that you don't have ANY connection to. I do think the connection can be really minor (I like to think I have very little in common with my characters who rape, kill, cheat, lie), or very obvious (I have a couple characters whom I can really relate to--I have writers, bibliophiles, characters who get picked on a lot, characters who feel really out of place in the world).

I've also had characters who have their own minds, who decide they want to be something other than what I originally intended them to be. I find it easier to change plot or circumstances than I do to change the personalities of the people in my stories. Once a personality takes root, that's how the character is going to be. :giggle:

I see rasp's comment, and your reply, and now I am QUITE curious, so I will be scrolling up and seeing what all that was about...
Reply
:iconsilverinkblot:
SilverInkblot Featured By Owner Dec 2, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
I'm pretty with you there - I'd rather change my plot than a good character. If that means they end up in a more difficult situation than intended, well, I'd better start getting more creative to get the out of it :B

The thing with *raspil actually began in this comment thread: [link] When he/she came to my poll with that comment, I could immediately see they had no interest in a reasonable discussion, so I blocked the account to avoid letting things get out of hand/ incite any public drama.
Reply
:iconsurrealcachinnation:
SurrealCachinnation Featured By Owner Dec 2, 2012   Writer
Yeah, exactly. I think plot is super important--there has to be a good plot, or I won't keep reading--but if the characters are good, well-rounded and dynamic, I think you can justify saying "Well, yeah, that'd make the plot hella easier to write, but he/she just wouldn't DO that."

Knowing *raspil, she probably took your making this poll the wrong way, thinking you were trying to prove a point or something. Knowing you, you're genuinely curious to see what people think about the process and characters and such. I think you two just aren't seeing eye to eye. I'd be annoyed if someone came to my poll and left that kind of comment, though, so I totally understand your reason for blocking. :P

...Actually, this is kinda funny, because I just realized *raspil 's recent forum post probably stemmed from the same thing this poll did. In her post, she was talking more about one-dimensonal pet characters than characters in general. I saw that post before I saw your poll, or the conversation either thing came from. I wound up commenting saying yes, plot is important, but good characters are, too, and she agreed. :shrug:
Reply
:iconleonca:
Leonca Featured By Owner Dec 1, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Most of my characters are an extension of some aspect of myself, or represent some trait I wish I could have. I have control over them, though the plot can surprise me sometimes. I have a bad habit of not planning things out in stories, and will often think of details to flesh them out as I write.
Reply
:iconsilverinkblot:
SilverInkblot Featured By Owner Dec 1, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
I don't do much planning either. Sometimes I might have a goal in mind, but it's usually something like "use mathematical terms to forge an emotional response" or something abstract like that. When I do plan, I feel like it takes something away; I feel obligated to stick to the plan.
Reply
:iconglossolalias:
glossolalias Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012
i create characters before i create plots; characters make or break great literature. my characters may not be "real" but they influence my writing because they make up the bulk of it, especially because i tend to write stories centric to the human element.
Reply
:iconsilverinkblot:
SilverInkblot Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
I think I identify with characters more than anything else as well, even when reading. Even if you've got a fantastic story, I usually feel the need to get attached to at least one character. If I can't, I kinda lose interest.
Reply
:iconglossolalias:
glossolalias Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012
i don't necessarily need to feel "attached" to a character so much as the characters need to seem like they're more than plot devices. "real" i suppose, if you understand. maybe authentic is a better word? anyway, there are genres where looser characterization works ( high fantasy&action&horror especially, though there are always exceptions) because the audience has already suspended their belief so far that they are really only engaging with the environment/plot (see james cameron's avatar), but generally speaking, i like the characters to tell the story, through their thoughts, actions, progressions, etc. people are my favorite animal, and they're worlds inside themselves.
Reply
:iconsilverinkblot:
SilverInkblot Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
I definitely understand - like, I always get kinda weirded out by shows with excessive fanservice because it feels like the characters are being treated like toys. Which is worse than treating them like plot devices to me.

And I can see what you mean about looser characterization as well; in something like a deconstructive work, exaggerating their character traits can make a point about the genre or archetype. (I kind of love deconstruction, so forgive my tangent :XD:)
Reply
:iconglossolalias:
glossolalias Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012
oh, definitely. characters are one thing; ideas are another, and the people in books can be one or the other: characters genuinely imitating life or ideas in human skin. i wouldn't say one's superior; it depends on the genre and execution. it isn't necessarily wrong to use characters as plot devices either, but i don't believe works like that ever reach merit. they're usually works for entertainment, which fills a (very big) niche in the market.

(it's okay, i tend to ramble too)
Reply
:iconaustori:
Austori Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
When I'm writing, I'm solidifying a dreamy outline of another world in my head and trying my best to get all the essence down on paper which is sometimes very hard to do. But, I treat my characters as real, they just live in a different dimension, that's all :-)
Reply
:iconsilverinkblot:
SilverInkblot Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
I like the different dimension idea as well. Even if that dimension is only in my head.
Reply
:iconaustori:
Austori Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Yup :-)
another thing I like to do to make my characters seem more realistic and get a better feeling of whatever storyline i had in mind is listen to music then try and cast the characters into a music video. It's quite fun
Reply
:iconsilverinkblot:
SilverInkblot Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
I've never associated my characters with a particular song, though I've seen a lot of authors do that. I've never been very musically inclined though :XD:
Reply
:iconaustori:
Austori Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
thats okay because you make pretty music when you write :-)
Reply
:iconsilverinkblot:
SilverInkblot Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
Thank you :aww:
Reply
:iconraspil:
raspil Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012   Writer
isn't this just precious
Reply
:iconsilverinkblot:
SilverInkblot Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
I can see I have no hope of having any decent conversation with someone who feels there's only one correct way to write :shrug: Sorry my process doesn't appeal to you, but that's no reason to be an asshole.
Reply
Add a Comment:
 

Poll History